Skip to content

Template

Customer Service Checklist: QA Evaluation Form and Template

A free customer service checklist for QA reviews: what to check on every chat, email and call, how to score it, plus IT help desk and audit items.

· Updated · 12 min read

Reviewed by Dominik Blattner, founder of Kaizo

Part of: QA Scorecard: Framework, Examples, Template and Scoring Maths

A customer service checklist for quality assurance is a short list of things every support conversation should get right, grouped into solution, tone and efficiency, each with a clear standard and a score.

The tables below are a complete QA checklist and evaluation form you can copy into your customer service QA scorecard, with extra items for IT help desks and a checklist for auditing the whole operation.

In short

  • Score every conversation on solution, empathy and tone, and efficiency.
  • Write down what good looks like for each item, or reviewers will disagree.
  • Weight items by risk: a wrong answer costs more than a typo.
  • Add channel or team items (calls, IT help desk) instead of building a second form.
  • Review the checklist every quarter so it matches your product and policies.

What is a customer service quality assurance checklist?

It is the list of criteria your reviewers use to grade support conversations, with a definition of “good” and a scoring rule for each one. It turns “was this a good reply?” into questions two reviewers can answer the same way.

The hardest part of setting up a customer service QA program is usually this first step: deciding what quality means for your team. There is no single correct answer. A checklist built for a software help desk will look different from one for a retailer or a bank, because the products, the risks and the customers differ. Start from the template below and cut or add items until it fits. Once it settles, it becomes the backbone of your QA scorecards.

Why you need a QA checklist

You need a QA checklist because it makes reviewers grade the same conversation the same way, so scores and coaching mean something. A checklist standardizes how you review calls, chats and emails. Without one, every reviewer grades on gut feel, agents get contradictory feedback and the scores mean little. Voice teams can start from our call center QA checklist.

With one, you can:

  • Spot problem areas in your service process, not just in individual replies.
  • Show new agents exactly what is expected of them.
  • Find patterns: the same item failing across a whole team usually points to a training gap or a broken process.
  • Give coaching a concrete starting point instead of a vague “be more empathetic”.

The customer service QA checklist

The customer service QA checklist has three categories, solution, empathy and tone, and efficiency, with a written standard and a scoring rule for every item.

customer service QA checklist with solution, tone and efficiency items

The checklist has three categories. Each item has a standard and a suggested way to score it. Use Yes / No / N/A where the item either happened or did not, and a 0 to 2 scale (missed, partly, fully) where quality varies.

1. Solution

The most important category: did the agent actually solve the customer’s problem?

ItemWhat good looks likeHow to score it
Solved the customer’s issueThe issue is fixed, or the customer knows exactly what happens nextYes / No, highest weight. Many teams make a No an auto-fail
Gave alternatives when neededWhen the answer is “no”, the agent offers a workable optionYes / No / N/A
Showed product knowledgeAccurate answer, no guessing, correct help article linked0 to 2: wrong, partly right, fully right
Answered every questionEvery question gets a reply, including the one buried in the last lineYes / No
Gave a timelineThe customer knows when to expect the fix or the next updateYes / No / N/A
Encouraged self-servicePoints to the article or setting so the customer can do it alone next timeYes / No / N/A, low weight
Kept promisesAny promised update or callback happened on timeYes / No. Check the ticket history, not just the last reply

2. Empathy and tone

An agent’s ability to show empathy and use the right tone can be the difference between a good review and a bad one. Scoring it separately shows exactly where an agent can improve.

ItemWhat good looks likeHow to score it
GreetingA greeting that fits the channel, using the customer’s nameYes / No, low weight
Brand toneReads like your company, as described in your tone-of-voice guide0 to 2
Positive tone throughoutStays calm and friendly, also when the customer is not0 to 2
Spelling and grammarNo errors that change the meaning or look carelessYes / No, or deduct per error up to a cap
Took the leadSets out the next steps instead of waiting for the customer to askYes / No
Empathy and apologyAcknowledges the impact in plain words and apologizes when the company is at fault0 to 2
Built trustThe customer ends the conversation confident in the answer0 to 2
Emojis and GIFsUsed only where your brand allows it and the mood fitsYes / No / N/A
ClosingThanks the customer and offers further helpYes / No, low weight

3. Efficiency

Efficiency is about more than speed. It means using time and tools well enough to solve the issue once and avoid a repeat contact.

ItemWhat good looks likeHow to score it
Resolved in good timeResolved within your target for this contact typeYes / No against your SLA
Used macros wellMacro used where it fits, then edited to answer this customerYes / No / N/A
ConciseThe answer is short and complete, with no wall of text0 to 2
Accurate notesA colleague could pick up the case from the notes without rereading the threadYes / No
Correct categorizationTags and fields set correctly, so reporting holds upYes / No
Prevented a follow-upAnticipated the obvious next question and answered itYes / No / N/A

Download the checklist

You can copy the tables above, or download the checklist as a free e-book to share with your reviewers. Want it as a file you can share with your reviewers? The customer service quality assurance checklist e-book is the free downloadable version. To run it as a live, weighted scorecard instead of a document, see Kaizo Scorecards.

How to score a customer service evaluation checklist

Score the checklist by giving each item a weight that reflects its risk, marking it Yes, No, N/A or 0 to 2, and adding the result into a percentage per conversation. Then check that the percentage moves with CSAT and repeat contacts. A checklist only helps if you can measure with it, so focus on two things.

Internal scoring

Give each item points and a weight, so the score reflects what matters. For example, spelling and grammar might be worth 10 of the 50 points in the empathy and tone category, while “solved the issue” carries far more weight than the greeting. The result per conversation is your Internal Quality Score, and it makes coaching needs easy to pinpoint.

Before you roll it out, have two or three reviewers score the same ten conversations. Where they disagree, the “what good looks like” column needs rewriting.

Quality metrics

Next, check whether the checklist is improving results, using a performance metrics scorecard. Track:

  • Customer Satisfaction Score (CSAT): how satisfied the customer was with the solution, usually as a percentage.
  • Net Promoter Score (NPS): the answer, from 0 to 10, to “How likely is it that you would recommend us to a friend or colleague?”
  • Negative Response Rate (NRR): negative ratings an agent or team receives compared with positive ones, as a percentage.
  • First Contact Resolution (FCR): the percentage of requests resolved in the first contact.
  • Repeat Contact Rate (RCR): the percentage of solved tickets reopened because the issue was not fixed.

If QA scores rise and these metrics do not move, your checklist is measuring the wrong things.

A worked example: one chat scored with the checklist

A customer writes in chat that their order arrived damaged and asks for a replacement. The agent apologizes, sends a replacement, adds the right tag, and closes the chat in six minutes. It looks like a clean pass. Scored item by item, it is not:

ItemResultWhy
Solved the customer’s issueYesReplacement sent
Answered every questionNoThe customer also asked whether to return the damaged item; nobody answered
Gave a timelineNoNo delivery date for the replacement
Empathy and apology2 of 2Acknowledged the damage in plain words
Correct categorizationYesTagged as damaged on arrival
Prevented a follow-upNoThe unanswered return question will come back as a second contact

With “answered every question” and “gave a timeline” weighted as solution items, this chat lands well below a typical pass mark, and the coaching point is specific: read the whole message before replying, and always close with a date. On email, the same two misses usually force a second reply, which is why the checklist uses identical wording on every channel.

How to adapt the checklist for phone calls

Add four call-only rows (recording announcement, identity verification, hold handling, spoken summary) and keep everything else identical.

To use this checklist as a call center quality assurance form, keep the solution, tone and efficiency items and add the few criteria that only exist on a call: the recording announcement, identity verification before account details, hold and dead-air handling, and a spoken summary of next steps. Score them the same way, so calls and chats stay comparable.

In practice that means four extra rows in the efficiency and tone tables, not a second form. Teams that run a separate phone form often end up with two quality numbers that cannot be compared. For a full call QA form with suggested weights and auto-fail criteria, see the guide to call monitoring, and for phase-by-phase call items, the checklist for every call phase.

Checklist items for IT customer service and help desks

An IT customer service checklist keeps the same three categories and adds items for diagnosis, access and handover, because a technical ticket fails in different places than a retail chat.

Add these rows to the solution and efficiency tables when your team supports software, internal IT or technical products:

ItemWhat good looks likeHow to score it
Priority and impact set correctlySeverity matches the impact on the user or business, not the tone of the messageYes / No
Reproduced or diagnosed before answeringThe agent confirmed the cause instead of sending a generic fix0 to 2
Troubleshooting steps documentedEvery step tried is in the ticket, so the next tier does not repeat itYes / No
Identity verified before access changesPassword resets and permission changes only after the agreed verificationYes / No, auto-fail if skipped
Clean escalationEscalated with steps to reproduce, logs or screenshots, and the user told what happens nextYes / No / N/A
Fix confirmed with the userThe ticket closes after the user confirms it works, or after a stated follow-up windowYes / No
Knowledge base updatedA new or recurring issue gets an article, or the existing one is correctedYes / No / N/A, low weight

Score them on the same scale as the rest, so your IT queue and your general support queue produce comparable numbers. If identity checks matter to your security policy, treat a skipped check as an auto-fail rule rather than a deduction.

Customer service audit checklist: reviewing the whole operation

A customer service audit checklist reviews the system behind the conversations, such as coverage, calibration, standards and coaching, rather than scoring individual tickets.

The checklist above grades one conversation at a time. Once a quarter, step back and audit the program that produces those scores. These are the questions to answer:

Audit areaWhat to checkWarning sign
CoverageWhat share of conversations gets scored, per channel and teamWhole queues or channels never reviewed
SamplingHow conversations are picked for reviewReviewers choose their own tickets
CalibrationWhen reviewers last scored the same conversations and comparedScores for the same agent differ by reviewer
Checklist currencyWhether items match current products, policies and channelsItems every agent passes every time
Coaching follow-upWhether failed items lead to coaching and a re-checkThe same item fails month after month
Customer signalsWhether QA scores move with CSAT and repeat contactsQA rises while CSAT and repeat contacts do not improve
Knowledge base and macrosWhether agents have current answers to the questions that failAgents quoting old policies

The free quality assurance checklist e-book is built for exactly this end-to-end audit of a support quality program.

Applying the checklist to every conversation

To apply the checklist to every conversation instead of a sample, let AI score each ticket against it and keep reviewers for calibration and failed conversations.

Most teams review a few conversations per agent per week, so the checklist describes a small sample. Quiet failures, like a promise nobody kept, rarely make it into that sample. With AutoPilot, Kaizo scores 100% of your chat, email and ticket conversations against your own scorecard, so the checklist applies to every ticket instead of a handful. Reviewers then spend their time on calibration and on the conversations that failed.

See it in a live demo. Kaizo scores 100% of your support conversations and turns the findings into coaching. Let’s talk.

When this checklist is not for you

This checklist is more than you need for a very small team and less than you need for a regulated phone line.

If your team handles a few dozen conversations a week, a lead can read them all and a one-page version of this checklist in a spreadsheet is enough. If you run a regulated phone line, treat the checklist as a starting point only: your compliance items come from your own legal and compliance advisors, not from a template.

Make it your own

Make the checklist your own by cutting items that never fail and adding the ones your customers complain about.

Every support team defines quality a little differently. Treat this checklist as a starting point. Drop items that never fail, add the ones your customers complain about, and revisit the list whenever your product, policies or channels change.

Turn this checklist into a working scorecard

A checklist becomes a working scorecard when each item has a weight, a scoring rule and, for the few critical items, an auto-fail. Keep the wording identical across channels, calibrate two or three reviewers on the same conversations, and revisit the weights every quarter. In a live demo we will show you which checks hold up in review, which ones reviewers disagree on, and which to drop.

Let's talk Contact

Frequently asked questions

What should be on a customer service QA checklist?

Items in three groups: solution (did the agent solve the issue, accurately and completely), empathy and tone (greeting, brand voice, empathy, spelling) and efficiency (speed, notes, categorization, preventing a follow-up). Each item needs a written standard so reviewers score it the same way.

How do you score a customer service QA checklist?

Use Yes / No / N/A for items that either happened or did not, and a 0 to 2 scale for items where quality varies. Weight the items by risk, so a wrong answer costs more than a missing greeting. Add the points into a percentage per conversation.

What is the difference between a QA checklist and a QA scorecard?

The checklist is the list of criteria. The QA scorecard is the checklist with weights, scoring rules and auto-fails attached, used to grade each conversation. In practice most teams build the checklist first and turn it into a scorecard.

How often should you update your QA checklist?

Review it every quarter, and whenever you launch a product, change a policy or add a channel. Remove items every agent passes every time, because they add work without telling you anything.

What is a call center quality assurance form?

A call center quality assurance form is the scorecard a reviewer fills in for each call: the criteria, a definition of a pass, a weight and a score per item, plus separate auto-fail items. It is the checklist above with a few call-only rows, such as verification and hold handling, added.

Is there a free customer service QA checklist template?

Yes. Copy the tables above, or download the free QA checklist e-book for a version you can share with your team.

In KaizoScorecardsA scorecard is where your standards stop being tribal knowledge. Build criteria in the words your business already uses, and every conversation gets measured against them.See Scorecards

On this page

See this in a live demo

We will walk you through Kaizo with realistic sample conversations, so you see the example scored, explained and coached.

Trusted by global support teams

  • Foot Locker
  • Canva
  • GetYourGuide
  • Instacart
  • BlaBlaCar
  • UiPath